What is the difference between supplements and nootropics?

As both a personal trainer and psychotherapist, I’m often asked what is the difference between supplements and nootropics and what I would recommend. These questions are becoming more frequent, especially with the growing interest in both physical and mental health, coupled with their increasing popularity on social media. I find that customers, clients, and patients want to know what they can take to improve their training results, strengthen their bodies, or gain a mental edge, whether for work, studies, or just to have a better everyday life. Here, I’ll dive into what actually distinguishes these two categories from each other, and which might work best for you.

What are Supplements?

Supplements are something most people are familiar with and have heard of. You see them everywhere from gyms to grocery stores, ranging from vitamins and minerals to proteins, amino acids, and omega-3 supplements. But what exactly are supplements, and why are they so popular and widespread?

Definition and Purpose

Supplements are products designed to complement a regular diet with nutrients that one might not get enough of through ordinary food. They’re often used to support general health, improve bodily functions, and even enhance performance during exercise. As a personal trainer, I often see people using protein powder to get enough protein to build muscle (about 1.25 grams per kg of body weight), or multivitamins to ensure they get the necessary vitamins and minerals

Types of Supplements

There are many different types of supplements. Vitamins and minerals are the most basic, but we also have protein powders, amino acids, omega-3 fatty acids, and specific sports products like creatine and pre-workout. Each of these has a specific purpose. For example, creatine is known for improving strength and muscle growth, while pre-workout provides energy and endurance during training. Omega-3, on the other hand, is fantastic for brain health and has anti-inflammatory properties

Benefits of Supplements

The benefits of supplements are numerous. They contribute where there are nutritional deficiencies, support the immune system, increase energy levels, and even improve recovery after exercise. When working with clients, I often see how much better they perform when they get the right nutrients through both food and supplements.

Why Not Use Supplements?

A balanced and good diet is usually sufficient to meet the body’s needs for vitamins, minerals, and other nutrients. By eating a varied diet with plenty of vegetables, proteins, and healthy fat sources, the body gets everything it needs to function optimally. Supplements can often be unnecessary, and in some special cases, they can even disturb the natural balances of nutrients in the body. Bioavailability is another factor in this; it turns out that bioavailability in some cases proves to be better in natural food. Therefore, it’s important to focus on achieving a healthy diet rather than relying solely on supplements, unless there’s a specific medical and examined reason to use them. Where you’ve looked into what you need and why. Another aspect is price and money; supplements are often disproportionately expensive, also in relation to the quality you actually get. The important thing here is to realize that supplements are something you take in addition to a balanced good diet, not instead of.

What are Nootropics?

This is something many of my clients and patients wonder about, and perhaps not a concept that’s well-known here in Norway, but in Europe, North America, and especially Asia, it’s well-known.

Nootropics can be both natural and synthetic. Natural nootropics include Rhodiola Rosea, Ginkgo Biloba, and L-theanine (see separate article on L-Theanine). Others are more on the mushroom side, including Lion’s Mane, which is one of the most well-documented (see separate article). Synthetic nootropics can include substances such as modafinil or piracetam, both of which are categorized as medicines here in Norway and are extremely potent. Other more well-known nootropics that people might not think about are coffee and tea, which contain caffeine and L-Theanine

Definition of Nootropics

If we look at the current definition of what nootropics are, it says they are substances intended to improve brain function. This includes better memory, increased focus, improved learning ability, and generally sharper mental performance. As a psychotherapist, I’ve seen how nootropics can support cognitive function and performance ability, especially for those experiencing mental fatigue, mental balance, and concentration difficulties (see article Anne Marlene).

Benefits of Nootropics

The benefits of nootropics can be significant, especially if you’re striving to improve mental performance. They can clearly contribute to better concentration, improved learning ability, and increased creativity. At the same time, many experience that nootropics help against stress and improve sleep quality. It has also been shown that nootropics have a good effect on mental issues such as depression, restlessness, anxiety, and ADHD. (See article on L-Theanine and Marine Magnesium) Which in turn can improve mental performance.

What is the difference between supplements and nootropics?

I’ll address here what really is the difference between these two. Although both can improve your health, they work in very different ways.

Main Differences:

In their properties and what they are targeted towards. Supplements primarily focus on improving the body’s physical health by providing essential nutrients. Nootropics, on the other hand, are designed to improve mental performance and cognitive function. On the other hand, these can also cross each other, where one and the other can be both a supplement and a nootropic

Users and Areas of Use:

Those who use or take supplements are often looking to improve their general health or exercise performance / physical performance, while those who use nootropics are often more focused on improving mental sharpness, productivity, or combating mental fatigue.

Of course, there’s also a correlation between those who focus on mental health also focusing on the physical and vice versa. In this way, one can say focus on general health, physical and mental / psychological, and that these go hand in hand.

How to Choose the Right Product for You

To choose between supplements and nootropics, it’s primarily about what the goal is and the desired end situation. If your goal is to improve physical health, such as building muscle or supporting the immune system, supplements are the way to go. If, on the other hand, you want to improve your mental performance, nootropics are probably more appropriate.

As both a personal trainer and psychotherapist, I always recommend clients to consider both. Where one wants to optimize health from both sides, and where they affect each other optimally. So that in this way, you get the best of both worlds

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *